
Despite being reported By the Republican Newspaper, Mondays night's Transfer Station Hearing was sparsely attended again. Maybe two, or three new faces I hadn't seen before. This process is dragging out so long I'm getting to know many of the people involved.

This ninth session started out with Daniel Ross from the Hope group telling a story of bringing his six year old son to the hospital after being waken in the night struggling for breath due to asthma.

Before Hope's first witness, Nora Travis, from Keene State College testified there was an issue of emailed copies of her power point presentation not getting to everyone. This led to Hope asking if everyone had received another power point presentation from another witness. None of the other participants had heard of this witness. Names of witnesses must be disclosed a week in advance, and the Board of Health's lawyer sent out an affirmative email describing the information he received listing Hope's 3 witnesses. He stated nobody responded that there was another witness.
Ginetta Candelario from Hope aired complaints about the regulations of the process calling it, "very demanding and frankly often anti-democratic", but Hearing officer Arthur Kreiger stated he didn't think it helped their position to go after the process. He allowed Nora Travis's testimony to go forward ruling against any motion to exclude her because of the email issues.

In her presentation Doctor Travis stated diesel engines pose a major environmental health, and public health concern. She linked diesel particulate matter with Asthma, Chronic Bronchitis, COPD, Cardiopulmonary Mortality, and Cancer. During questioning by the board of health she stresses how biodiesel can reduce particulate emissions. She also cited many mitigation methods already covered in previous sessions. Doctor Travis was not at any previous hearings, and wasn't aware that everything she cited had already been recommended by the Board of Health's own experts.
Doctor Travis admitted that some of the new science she referred to was controversial among scientist. The Board of Health had a hard time wrapping their heads around the concepts. The EPA's recommendations seemed to conflict, and the Board wanted to know if Doctor Travis was saying, "that's all wrong". She replied, "I'm not Nora Travis saying that, I can refer you to a list of other scientist that are saying that." Saying further, "Based on the evidence Ive seen I lean towards caution with the newer evidence."
Hope's cross examination didn't add any new facts, and United Waste reserved the right to cross examine Doctor Travis during the next hearing date.

Springdale resident Joel Patruno spoke as a
Witness of fact for Hope. All other witnesses up to this point had been
Witnesses of Testimony. He billed himself as an expert for the Springdale Neighborhood, its people, and land. He spoke for 45 minutes. Impassionedly at times. About this take on the proposed project, the makeup of the neighborhood, and how he felt it would impact it.
It was actually touching to hear him put so much of himself into his presentation, even if I don't agree with much of what he said, its was all him. His personality, quirks, and foibles all came out. And he put it all on the line for an issue he is passionate about. He was the only witness to receive an applause.
At the end of the hearing things got complicated. Arthur Kreiger commented that Doctor Travis's testimony could be stricken from the record if she is not available for cross examination at the next hearing.
Discussion turned to Hope calling several new witness not previously known. United Waste stated they would not grant any further extensions of the hearing after already extending it twice. Saying,"frankly, there's been months and months to do this and it's just extending the hearing." in reference to Hope's requests for concessions.
Hearing officer Kreiger ruled to continue through Monday February 2nd, and laid down strict rules on filing testimony by Wednesday the 28th. Lawyer for United Waste requested all the names of potential witnesses for Hope since he would only have 2 days to review their testimony. Kreiger also ruled against allowing testimony from one of Hope's proposed witnesses saying, "I've heard his presentation before - It is generic - It is not Holyoke specific." Hope objected stating his testimony was allowed in other communities. Kreiger said "I know, I allowed it before."
Upon hearing of 6 potential witnesses in 3 hours on Monday the Board of Health baulked with one member saying, "It can't be done!"
Kreiger began laying down time limits, but the Board of Health complained that if there's any more repetition of testimony it's a waste of time.
With the Monday hearing looking to a final showdown I'll be filming from multiple angles with Director Sergio Leone. The Board of health's Lawyer will be played by Clint Eastwood, Ginetta Candelario by Ginetta Candelario, Arthur Kreiger by Eli Wallach, and United Waste's Lawyer by Lee Van Cleef. Music by
Ennio Morricone.
.